Broadband Blog

Ring Side view of Indian Telecom Circus

Tortoise wins the race?

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

The hare and tortoise is the classic adage that taught the virtues of going slow. Had the hare not rested, he would have won. It was stupidity on his part. The tortoise had nothing to loose and was slowly walking towards the “goal”- the original story doesn’t mention as to how long it took tortoise to win.

However, it seems that Indian telecom operators have embraced the tortoise approach rather too seriously. While a tortoise may move, these seem to have their boots leadened up- they refuse to drag.

This is damning state of affairs- we are held hostage to a few glorified morons who draw fancy salaries and perks- without moving the things on the ground. Clearly, even in the name of IT- we are laggards. Suffice to say that we are happy to serve as “low cost destination” for offshoring- euphemism for cyber coolism.

Some attempt has been made to analyse the state of affairs Despite what the paid PRO’s claim, it is clear that are not on anyone’s radar.

Why am I peturbed?

I came across this link on Business Week which details South Korea’s broadband roll out

More on Emergic.org

It’s about the emerging scenario as to what the technology can do. Plus of course, the public and the private partnership. Excerpt:

What distinguishes South Korea’s effort is the intense cooperation between the IT industry and the government — in sharp contrast with the U.S., where the government devotes few resources to the development of and technologies. Indeed, the soul of many of Korea’s machines is not in the laboratories of Samsung Electronics Inc. or operator SK Telecom, but at the state-run Electronics & Telecommunications Research Institute (ETRI) in Daejon, 170 km south of Seoul.

Despite US agressive roll out, it is still a laggard as far as Japan is concerned This needs free registration at the website. (Avoid this by going to BugMeNot and type in the URL. You would get the login details)

Perhaps we may be condemned for ever to stay as a “developing country” identified as the third world nation while others race ahead. Most people learnt from the hare- to seize the initiative and rest not till one reaches the target. We refuse to learn from the tortoise.

 

Click through Related Posts
Its been a long hiatus; after the shift to a new job in a new place, things have finally settled down. I have been looking at the growth and the hype ...
READ MORE
Paid for Exposure in Is there a paid exposure? I had alluded to the same in one of my earlier posts on TechWhack. This article appears in Business ...
READ MORE
There are hosts of complex interrelated issues that need to be enumerated for the launch of broadband services by .I shall try and lay out a case. The current euphoria ...
READ MORE
Infocomm started a virtual war when it entered. With the largest user base in the country in mobile segment, it is on a breakneck speed in expanding its offerings ...
READ MORE
Indian Telecom is a Farce The old adage of the business rule is that it takes ten times more cost to earn a customer than to retain one. I am sure ...
READ MORE
Few details have trickled out in the media. Thats the testimony to the fact that these brothers have an iron grip over what is reported and what isn't. The settlement ...
READ MORE
This one is out of context here. Bitching about the different operators et al, leaves me exhausted. This one I owe it to one of my close friends. Seperated from ...
READ MORE
The underlying factor is the frustration that user's experience given the awful quality of the services. One feels helpless and unable to do anything about the same. There is a ...
READ MORE
Smaller Telecom Operators in India In the complex telecom muddle, there are a few independent operators that have stood the test of time and branched out on their own. However, the ...
READ MORE
A lot has been said about the 3 G services. It is claimed that it would usher us in the "next generation of Wireless access". Frankly, I have my reservations about ...
READ MORE
More on BSNL
Paid for Media Exposure in India
Reliance Infocomm
Indian Telecom is a Farce
Behind Reliance
Reliance- making it affordable for love struck
Is Privatization Panacea For All Ills?
Smaller Telecom Operators in India
3 G services- Why the hoopla?

This content is published under the Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Related posts:

  1. More on BSNL Its been a long hiatus; after the shift to a new job in a new place, things have finally settled...
  2. Paid for Media Exposure in India Paid for Media Exposure in India Is there a paid media exposure? I had alluded to the same in one...
  3. BSNL Broadband Hoopla There are hosts of complex interrelated issues that need to be enumerated for the launch of broadband services by BSNL.I...
  4. Reliance Infocomm Reliance Infocomm Reliance started a virtual war when it entered. With the largest user base in the country in mobile...
  5. Indian Telecom is a Farce Indian Telecom is a Farce The old adage of the business rule is that it takes ten times more cost...
  6. Behind Reliance Few details have trickled out in the media. Thats the testimony to the fact that these brothers have an iron...
  7. Reliance- making it affordable for love struck This one is out of context here. Bitching about the different operators et al, leaves me exhausted. This one I...
  8. Is Privatization Panacea For All Ills? The underlying factor is the frustration that user’s experience given the awful quality of the services. One feels helpless and...
  9. Smaller Telecom Operators in India Smaller Telecom Operators in India In the complex telecom muddle, there are a few independent operators that have stood the...
  10. 3 G services- Why the hoopla? A lot has been said about the 3 G services. It is claimed that it would usher us in the...

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

A very thoughtful analysis. But a bigger coultry has more in it's plate. We have far more human resource, far more other natural resources. Only the people who should be leading are eating money and doing nothing.

A very thoughtful analysis. But a bigger coultry has more in it's plate. We have far more human resource, far more other natural resources. Only the people who should be leading are eating money and doing nothing.

That S.Korea is ahead of the rest of the world or even Hong Kong for that matter is not surprising. THe majority of the population lives in a very densely populated city.

The US is slower to catch up cos its a *HUGE* country. If you live in a big city or near a major highway then the chances of broadband are good otherwise you are screwed. You have very limited and therfore expensive choice. WHy stop with the US, Australia is not faring any better either. Internet service there is quite expensive despite being a developed country.

The only large country with decent internet service is Cananda. When you consider the majoirty of the population lives in a narrow strip that borders the US coupled with a very forward thinking govt they got a good deal. But if the US was not on thier border i doubt things would have been as sweet.

The mobile phone situation in the US is a complicated one, they favour market forces to one standard ala GSM mandated from above. CDMA is way cheaper than GSM to deploy. I hear form friends there that call rates are dropping, Again huge country, not as easy as tiny densely populated european countries to deploy repeaters in.

So yes, it will take long to have universal broadband in India for the simple reason of geography. Unless broadband over power cables becomes feasible where we can have the power companies joing the group. But they got enough probs just trying to supply reliable power so maybe thats a bit too ambitious to try.

That S.Korea is ahead of the rest of the world or even Hong Kong for that matter is not surprising. THe majority of the population lives in a very densely populated city.

The US is slower to catch up cos its a *HUGE* country. If you live in a big city or near a major highway then the chances of broadband are good otherwise you are screwed. You have very limited and therfore expensive choice. WHy stop with the US, Australia is not faring any better either. Internet service there is quite expensive despite being a developed country.

The only large country with decent internet service is Cananda. When you consider the majoirty of the population lives in a narrow strip that borders the US coupled with a very forward thinking govt they got a good deal. But if the US was not on thier border i doubt things would have been as sweet.

The mobile phone situation in the US is a complicated one, they favour market forces to one standard ala GSM mandated from above. CDMA is way cheaper than GSM to deploy. I hear form friends there that call rates are dropping, Again huge country, not as easy as tiny densely populated european countries to deploy repeaters in.

So yes, it will take long to have universal broadband in India for the simple reason of geography. Unless broadband over power cables becomes feasible where we can have the power companies joing the group. But they got enough probs just trying to supply reliable power so maybe thats a bit too ambitious to try.

© 2009 Broadband Blog. All Rights Reserved.

This blog is powered by the Wordpress platform and beach rentals.