Business Standard finally wakes up to some reality and commisions a debate between ISP association of India and BSNL. I would have to quote freely from that to expose as to how BSNL claims ring hollow.
First, the version of Deepak Maheshwari, Secretary ISP association- he argues effectively for local loop unbundling.
“While Trai recommended unbundling of the last mile for broadband, the Broadband Policy stated that “last mile copper loop is not a ‘bottleneck facility’ for broadband services”, though it recorded that about 7 million copper pairs of the incumbent were suitable for broadband”
Broadband policy is flawed and utterly so. How can the likes of Maran claim that last mile isn’t a bottleneck? Assinine to say the least.
A chilling thought here:
“So far, less than 4 per cent of these have been put to use for broadband.”
Finally, the strong arguments for unbundling:
“Unbundling has not only ensured more choice to the end-users but has also enforced incumbents to be more agile and responsive to customer needs. Everywhere — in countries such as Japan, the UK, France and even Korea (the poster boy of broadband) — broadband access was accelerated thanks to unbundling.
Specially in UK, the unbundling has forced the incumbent British Telecom to shape up- BT is more or less like our own BSNL- worse off in some regards. Interesting to see as to how the brits left their legacy in more than one ways! Including this blog which is being written in English!
However, the current crop of ISP’s have been treated with disdain by the entrenched interests. There have been regular denials of connectivity and high access charges. Who else? Tata owned VSNL and our poster hate boy- BSNL. Surely, there is enough muck in the corridors of Telecom Department.
Now for BSNL’s retort- it reads like a press release. If you read closely enough, there is a tacit admission that much of the copper loops are useless. Testimony to the fact that BSNL has been extremely slow in upgrading it’s network.
A common tactic used to deflect the attention from the issues is to use “falutin”- thats the English term for “high sounding words”. For example, some of it is “World class“, “scorching pace“, “customer delight“,”fastest growing“,”cheapest“,”state of the art“,”high speed internet“( ha ha who guessed it?).”economic tool“,“millions of customers“…..
Readers are requested to add some words of their own.
Anyway, look at what R L Dube Director, Planning and New Services has to say about it. And how he falters in his own self belief. He has no idea about what broadband is and how it is accessed.
First salvo.
It crossed the 2-lakh subscriber base in nine months of its launch and is now adding an average of 4,000 customers across the country on a daily basis. By December 2005, we are sure we will cross the figure of 5 lakh( Whom are you kidding Mr Dube?)and by the end of the fiscal the target of one million.
Prepare yourself for a good laugh guys. This isnt me but the Director of Planning BSNL is saying. If we have “intelligent folks like these”- we surely know why BSNL is one of the worst telecom companies in the world.
“Broadband has to work on copper cables in the present network. It needs a computer with Pentium 4 and above and also a sound operating system.”
Sad reflection of the standards surely.
Another admission of BSNL which is loud and clear.
“And, instead of the existing billing system, a better state-of-the-art, transparent and customer-oriented system will be in place. We are sure it will do away all with all billing-related doubts.”
Nowhere in the article is mentioned that Mr Dube’s views are personal- this means he is speaking on behalf of BSNL.
A word of advice to BSNL. Kindly have knowledgeable people to defend your view point. If you can’t provide a decent service, have those people to speak for you who have some degree of intelligence.
How can they claim that broadband can’t run on computers other than Pentium 4? I am using an AMD- so sue me!
It’s the pits for sure and we have become the laughing stock of the entire world. Imagine. A director of a telecom company claiming such a thing about it’s services.
This is one post I couldn’t resist to highlight.
256 kbps which drops to slower-than-dial-up-speeds.This is BROADBAND INDIA for you guys
Pingback: Broadband Blog » Blog Archive » US and India similarities.
I think the person who wrote this blog sucks. The Broadband prices have come down because of the entry of BSNL in the BB market. I am very satisfied with the services and it has never let me down and the bandwidth being offered is very steady. What does this blog writer want to convey? does he want unbundling so that these private guys can operate and give BB at very high cost? I think talking of Pentium 4 and AMD really does not matter, it palys no part in this discussion of BB services. Pl plan before you want to write something down so that it makes some sense.
I think the person who wrote this blog sucks. The Broadband prices have come down because of the entry of BSNL in the BB market. I am very satisfied with the services and it has never let me down and the bandwidth being offered is very steady. What does this blog writer want to convey? does he want unbundling so that these private guys can operate and give BB at very high cost? I think talking of Pentium 4 and AMD really does not matter, it palys no part in this discussion of BB services. Pl plan before you want to write something down so that it makes some sense.
Thanks Santosh.
There are enough people who need to evolve. You are one of them. Abusing someone, even if you disagree with my personal opinion isnt just warranted.
Though in the name of fair play, I haven’t deleted your comment.
Thanks Santosh.
There are enough people who need to evolve. You are one of them. Abusing someone, even if you disagree with my personal opinion isnt just warranted.
Though in the name of fair play, I haven’t deleted your comment.
BSNL stands in its own puddle to say the least, but one up was their jumstart into anything broadband. I truly agree that it sucks holy cock, but whats important is that if BSNL unbundles its local loops, lets make sure they are still around. for the loops they are into, even BSNL can crack up their “organization” (cant see any there) and wind up cooked in mittal’s hands. i dont want private companies swaping big brother roles, with loops lying all around the country rotting. much of what you said makes sense except for the ol geezer Dube thingie
by the time you read this i should’ve downloaded the next kb.
BSNL stands in its own puddle to say the least, but one up was their jumstart into anything broadband. I truly agree that it sucks holy cock, but whats important is that if BSNL unbundles its local loops, lets make sure they are still around. for the loops they are into, even BSNL can crack up their “organization” (cant see any there) and wind up cooked in mittal’s hands. i dont want private companies swaping big brother roles, with loops lying all around the country rotting. much of what you said makes sense except for the ol geezer Dube thingie
by the time you read this i should’ve downloaded the next kb.
Thanks Sachin for dropping in. I wrote precisely the same thing as you have just mentioned. And yes Dube is an ole geezer. Probably moth infested brains?
http://broadbandblog.in/362/bsnl-unions-oppose-privatisation/
Thanks Sachin for dropping in. I wrote precisely the same thing as you have just mentioned. And yes Dube is an ole geezer. Probably moth infested brains?
http://broadbandblog.in/362/bsnl-unions-oppose-privatisation/
speaking in analogys I asked my mother a question on the concept of MRP this way:
a. if you are manufacturing something do you believe that you have the right to maximize the profits out of it since you are the sole monopoly/the best of the breed and have the biggest distribution model etc.– her answer was “yes”
b. do you believe we should remove MRP — her answer was “NO”
so statistics are all about the way the question is asked, I believe Humphery Appleby said something like that.
speaking in analogys I asked my mother a question on the concept of MRP this way:
a. if you are manufacturing something do you believe that you have the right to maximize the profits out of it since you are the sole monopoly/the best of the breed and have the biggest distribution model etc.– her answer was “yes”
b. do you believe we should remove MRP — her answer was “NO”
so statistics are all about the way the question is asked, I believe Humphery Appleby said something like that.