Broadband Blog

Ring Side view of Indian Telecom Circus

IPTV: Can this be pulled off?

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

In my earlier write ups on , I have mentioned about the metamorphosis of the telecom companies from mere voice carriers to entertainment delivery platforms. Content for is woefully inadequate and it does represent a huge untapped market for .

However, IPTV or Protocol Television would call for massive investments in the hardware/ delivery channels. At current speeds of 256k, it’s a no brainer give away that ’s rat infested exchanges would collapse like nine pins.

There has been some movement on ground earlier on. This is mentioned here. Given the current scenario, I was wondering whether the content would choke the existing lines. At present, Reliance is the only company that has firm plans for IPTV roll out.

So how do you marry today’s technology with the possible future? Interestingly, Ramesh Jain and Robert Cringely have the answers.

Dr. Ramesh Jain writes:

When Video on Demand first appeared, it was considered to be a vehicle for providing a time shifted TV for popular video content so people can watch any movie or a popular program at their convenience in the comfort of their home…It was clear that the cost of the infrastructure was too high compared to the demand. In place of VoD becoming a big buzz world, it slowly became dormant.

IPTV is in simple terms video on internet….This in fact is the convergence of communication, , and content.IPTV is a real transformation in the society. IPTV brings TV to masses not only as a consumer but also as a producer.

Robert Cringely has something else to write: ( My comments in the brackets)

The Internet television story, even as written here in columns going back as far as the late 1990s, pushed the idea of enabling the aggregation of widely-dispersed viewing audiences, allowing programming to thrive that might not be successful on any local station, much less on the national network. ( A locally produced TV show though having national relevance may not log in many viewers; for a wider platform like Internet, it can have a mass , because of the sheer size of the people accessing the content).

Robert further writes:

My reasoning came down to the price differential between Internet bandwidth and intranet bandwidth, the latter being that bandwidth entirely within the ISPs local point of presence or data center. There is a lot more of this intranet bandwidth, for one thing. Depending on how their network is segmented, a local provider of cable Internet or DSL service may have gigabits of aggregate customer bandwidth attached to a much smaller Internet pipe. A 100-to-one ratio of internal to external bandwith is typical, meaning the effective cost of internal bandwidth is 100 times lower…The advantages of this strategy are profound. Bandwidth costs go away completely, which not only frees up money for more programming or better servers, it becomes much more practical to display video with larger frame sizes, faster frame rates, and higher resolutions, creating a better viewing experience.

What’s in this for the phone and cable companies is revenue sharing for , as well as reducing demand on the ISP’s own Internet connection. They’ll understand instantly and see the revenue and cost-saving potential.

This means that a local cache of the content would serve the IPTV better. This seems to be BSNL’s strategy; the promised IBM servers would be installed by this month end.

This does open up the possibility to work around with the content, deliver the latest Rakhi Sawant videos to the consumers. No, none of the Techwhack guys are any big fans of Rakhi Sawant; though, I am sure there would be many eager beavers to lap her pelvic thrusts online. Porn, perhaps, would find itself here too. Time Shift TV may be a reality soon. For all those who missed the wardrobe malfunction in Bombay’s Fashion Mela, you can rewind it and view it as many times as you wish. Or Baba Ramdev may be crooning with Mallika Sherawat soon on your Yoga channel delivered via Internet.

This is the future I am talking of.

 

Click through Related Posts
UT Starcom has set up shop in and planning to sell its equipment to BSNL. I am not sure what the news said- whether they are in the process ...
READ MORE
Content is the king. Really? I have reasons to doubt my earlier assertions. I was under the impression that content would drive the future growth of . Indeed, it was ...
READ MORE
When would jump in the broadband arena? Noone knows for sure. Plus its been debated ad nauseum in the various forums. Would entry of make any difference? I ...
READ MORE
I was indeed impressed by Reliance's scale and grandiosity. Reliance WAS the darling of the media and stock exchange. However, splitting up the family's fortunes was one of the stupidiest ...
READ MORE
has an eulogising report on : Looking at straddling the entire value chain of the entertainment content carriageway, the group is ensuring its footprints across every ...
READ MORE
Some good news finally. won the case in Supreme Court- though after being scuttled by repeatedly over the bandwidth issue. This had resulted in huge cost for the end ...
READ MORE
I got a reply from some of the BSNL's staffer's; most likely PA to the CMD. Here is the mail: This is in reference to the mail sent to CMD ...
READ MORE
Ho hum. We all know about it right? Well, it seems that Reliance is extending it's launch date by another 3 months. They do have commercial services in couple ...
READ MORE
Insanities offered by BSNL has finally jumped in the broadband arena with a watered down offering. However, there is much more than that meets the eye and the primary ...
READ MORE
I chanced on CNET write up about the "need for speeds". Triple play carrying voice/ data and video is a common place. Yet, an average Joe like us uses Internet ...
READ MORE
IPTV ahoy!
Broadband: Content would choke
Anil Ambani- the next media mogul?
Reliance Infocomm- The next entertainment bigwig?
Bandwidth rates fall
Another mail to BSNL Broadband
Reliance Broadband: More delay
Insanities offered by BSNL Broadband
Broadband: How much do you really need?

This content is published under the Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Related posts:

  1. IPTV ahoy! UT Starcom has set up shop in India and planning to sell its equipment to BSNL. I am not sure...
  2. Broadband: Content would choke Content is the king. Really? I have reasons to doubt my earlier assertions. I was under the impression that content...
  3. Reliance Broadband When would Reliance jump in the broadband arena? Noone knows for sure. Plus its been debated ad nauseum in the...
  4. Anil Ambani- the next media mogul? I was indeed impressed by Reliance’s scale and grandiosity. Reliance WAS the darling of the media and stock exchange. However,...
  5. Reliance Infocomm- The next entertainment bigwig? Business Standard has an eulogising report on Anil Ambani: Looking at straddling the entire value chain of the entertainment content...
  6. Bandwidth rates fall Some good news finally. TRAI won the case in Supreme Court- though after being scuttled by VSNL repeatedly over the...
  7. Another mail to BSNL Broadband I got a reply from some of the BSNL’s staffer’s; most likely PA to the CMD. Here is the mail:...
  8. Reliance Broadband: More delay Ho hum. We all know about it right? Well, it seems that Reliance is extending it’s launch date by another...
  9. Insanities offered by BSNL Broadband Insanities offered by BSNL Broadband BSNL has finally jumped in the broadband arena with a watered down offering. However, there...
  10. Broadband: How much do you really need? I chanced on CNET write up about the “need for speeds”. Triple play carrying voice/ data and video is a...

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Oh cache is feasible (technically) but cache also implies storage which won't scale up and defeats the purpose of streaming over a network.

Not long ago it was possible to grab tv from nothing but thin air.

The connundrum is cable cos can do tv but not internet (as well as) telcos and vice versa. The players for the convergence are present already, but too specialised in their own areas. Winner will be who manages to do both for cheaper than each separately giving a product greater than the sum of its parts.

Not HDTV just plain tv data (and voice). The timing is right for this as most of these guys will be buying the equipment to do it from the west at bargain prices as they move to the next greatest thing.

Oh cache is feasible (technically) but cache also implies storage which won't scale up and defeats the purpose of streaming over a network.

Not long ago it was possible to grab tv from nothing but thin air.

The connundrum is cable cos can do tv but not internet (as well as) telcos and vice versa. The players for the convergence are present already, but too specialised in their own areas. Winner will be who manages to do both for cheaper than each separately giving a product greater than the sum of its parts.

Not HDTV just plain tv data (and voice). The timing is right for this as most of these guys will be buying the equipment to do it from the west at bargain prices as they move to the next greatest thing.

Precisely for this reason, I had mentioned about local cache to be kept which would reduce the latency.

You are right about the "killer app"; but then we never had any so far. Frankly, the mobile phone business has grown purely (or mostly) on the voice calls.

We'd wait for the things to unfold.

What's missing with IPTV atm is the killer app...

What does IPTV offer over more conventional TV, forget better quality, they will be offering the same as what you get from your local cable wallah, assuming it even gets this far.

Lets say there is an app, how does this compare with telling ppl to sms xxx with yyyy vs using a set top box, fiddling with a keyboard and iptv.

Are there any successful applications of IPTV anywhere in the world to justify the cost ?

American idol, Indian idol ...pfffft !!

The only compelling point is the triple play any provider gets, ie voice, data & video on one bill with one cable. I would surely dump my cable provider if Airtel could match their prices.

What i think is more likely instead of IPTv is that you will still get RF-modded signal coming from that same wire. So it would be like as if your cable wallah & telco merged into one.

Forget iPTV, its requires incredibly good latency and the only way to do that is have total control end to end, with high-end routers to ensure low error rate. Cos if ur cricket game starts skipping i gurantee most ppl will throw it out.

Precisely for this reason, I had mentioned about local cache to be kept which would reduce the latency.

You are right about the "killer app"; but then we never had any so far. Frankly, the mobile phone business has grown purely (or mostly) on the voice calls.

We'd wait for the things to unfold.

What's missing with IPTV atm is the killer app...

What does IPTV offer over more conventional TV, forget better quality, they will be offering the same as what you get from your local cable wallah, assuming it even gets this far.

Lets say there is an app, how does this compare with telling ppl to sms xxx with yyyy vs using a set top box, fiddling with a keyboard and iptv.

Are there any successful applications of IPTV anywhere in the world to justify the cost ?

American idol, Indian idol ...pfffft !!

The only compelling point is the triple play any provider gets, ie voice, data & video on one bill with one cable. I would surely dump my cable provider if Airtel could match their prices.

What i think is more likely instead of IPTv is that you will still get RF-modded signal coming from that same wire. So it would be like as if your cable wallah & telco merged into one.

Forget iPTV, its requires incredibly good latency and the only way to do that is have total control end to end, with high-end routers to ensure low error rate. Cos if ur cricket game starts skipping i gurantee most ppl will throw it out.

© 2009 Broadband Blog. All Rights Reserved.

This blog is powered by the Wordpress platform and beach rentals.